ABOUT US
About Best NY Pizza
Authentic New York-Style Pizza — Tampa’s Favorite Since 2005
Welcome to Best NY Pizza, where the unmistakable taste of true New York–style pizza comes to life in the heart of Tampa, Florida. Founded in 2005 by Brooklyn natives Greg and Pat, we bring over two decades of authentic NY pizza craftsmanship, family tradition, and community passion to every slice. Best NY Pizza
Our Story
Best NY Pizza began as a dream rooted in genuine New York pizza heritage. Greg and Pat carried their family’s time-honored recipes and artisan techniques from Brooklyn straight to Tampa Bay, with one goal in mind: to serve real New York–style pizza made the right way—hand-tossed, stone-baked, and never rushed. Best NY Pizza
From day one, we committed to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, making our dough and sauce from scratch daily, and perfecting baking techniques that deliver the iconic crispy outside and chewy inside crust beloved by pizza lovers everywhere.
What Sets Us Apart
At Best NY Pizza, pizza isn’t just food—it’s tradition. Our approach reflects the old-school methods of New York neighborhood pizzerias, with a modern, family-friendly twist that keeps locals coming back again and again. Best NY Pizza
-
Hand-tossed dough made fresh daily using high-gluten flour
-
Signature NY tomato sauce crafted for bold flavor
-
Premium cheeses and quality toppings
-
Stone deck ovens that bake pizzas quickly at high heat
-
A menu filled with classic NY pies, specialty pizzas, pasta, calzones, subs, wings, and more
Community & Recognition
We’re proud to be a family-owned, community-driven pizzeria that treats guests like neighbors. Over the years, we’ve had the honor of being named “Best Pizza in Tampa” by Creative Loafing and “Best Pizza in Tampa Bay” by the Tampa Bay Times—a testament to our commitment to quality and flavor. Best NY Pizza
From our early days serving slices to locals to becoming a go-to destination for families, visitors, and pizza purists, Best NY Pizza has earned a reputation for delivering true New York–style pizza experience in Florida.
Our Promise
We believe great pizza starts with fresh ingredients, expert technique, and passion for tradition. Whether you’re craving a classic cheese slice, a fully loaded specialty pie, or Italian comfort classics like calzones and pasta dinners, we make it with care—and serve it with genuine New York attitude.
Best NY Pizza isn’t just a name.
It’s our promise.
Best NY Pizza: Our Concept
Authentic New York–Style Pizza. Fresh Daily. No Shortcuts.
Best NY Pizza is a fast-casual New York–style pizzeria built on one simple mission: serve real NY pizza the way it’s meant to be made—with fresh ingredients, proven technique, and genuine hospitality.
From our hand-tossed dough to our stone-oven bake, everything we do is rooted in traditional New York pizzerias where pizza is the centerpiece, quality matters, and customers are treated like family
What Defines the Best NY Pizza Experience?
Real New York–Style Pizza
Great pizza starts with fundamentals. That’s why we:
-
Make our pizza dough fresh daily
-
Use high-quality tomato sauce and premium cheeses
-
Bake pizzas hot in stone ovens for the signature NY texture
(crispy bottom, chewy interior, foldable slice) -
Our menu features classic New York favorites—from cheese and pepperoni pizza to fully loaded specialty pies, along with traditional Italian comfort foods like garlic knots, meatballs, calzones, and pasta dinners.
Fresh Ingredients. Crafted Daily.
We believe freshness is non-negotiable. Every pizza is made to order using carefully selected ingredients and time-tested methods. From classic toppings like pepperoni and mushrooms to bold combinations of meats and vegetables, each pie is built for balance, flavor, and consistency.
This commitment to quality is what separates authentic New York pizza from everything else.
A Welcoming, Casual Pizzeria Atmosphere
Best NY Pizza is designed to feel like a true neighborhood pizzeria—relaxed, welcoming, and unpretentious. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice, feeding the family, or sitting down for a full meal, our goal is simple:
great food, served hot, in a place you’ll want to come back to.
Service That Feels Personal
Exceptional customer service isn’t an add-on—it’s part of who we are. We believe the best pizzerias are built on relationships. That means:
-
Knowing our customers
-
Listening to feedback
-
Making sure every visit feels familiar and satisfying
When you walk into Best NY Pizza, you’re not just another order—you’re part of our extended pizza family.
Why Customers Choose Best NY Pizza
-
Authentic New York–style pizza
-
Fresh dough and ingredients made daily
-
Stone-oven baking for real NY texture
-
Generous portions and classic recipes
-
Friendly, neighborhood-style service
Our Promise
At Best NY Pizza, we don’t chase trends—we focus on doing New York pizza right.
Quality ingredients. Honest recipes. Consistent execution.
Best NY Pizza isn’t just a name.
It’s our promise—every slice, every time.
Roots of Pizza in NYC
New York City is known for many things, but one of its most iconic foods is undoubtedly pizza. The history of pizza in NYC is a long and storied one, with roots that stretch back to the early 19th century.
The Beginning of Pizza in NYC
The first pizza in NYC is believed to have been sold by G. Lombardi's Grocery Store, which opened in 1905. Lombardi's, located on Spring Street in Little Italy, is considered the first pizzeria in the United States. The pizza was a simple, thin-crust pizza, made with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and a few toppings.
The Evolution of Pizza in NYC
As pizza became more popular in NYC, it began to evolve. Pizza makers started experimenting with different toppings and styles, and the pizza began to take on new forms. One of the most popular styles of pizza in NYC is the Neapolitan pizza, which is characterized by its thick, fluffy crust and sweet tomato sauce. Another popular style of pizza in NYC is the New York-style pizza, which is characterized by its large, thin crust and generous toppings. This style of pizza is often sold by the slice and is a staple of many NYC pizzerias.
Pizza Today in NYC
Today, pizza in NYC is more diverse than ever. You can find pizza in every borough, from classic Neapolitan-style pizza to innovative toppings and styles. Pizza in NYC has become a true melting pot of flavors, with influences from all over the world.
In addition to traditional pizzerias, you can also find pizza trucks, food trucks and pop-ups that offer unique and creative pizza options.