LOCATIONS
Thanksgiving: CLOSED Christmas Eve: 11am-8pm Christmas Day: CLOSED
New Years Eve: 11am-8pm New Years Day: Open at 12pm
-
“Where other shops stop, we keep going.”
-
“Carrollwood or Wesley Chapel — the same exact NY flavor.”
-
“We’re the only NY pizza shop offering slices, Sicilian, wings, pasta & catering.”
COME VISIT US
CARROLLWOOD
14741 North Dale Mabry Hwy
Tampa, FL 33618
813.963.7600
WESLEY CHAPEL
27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd
Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
813.994.2200
Service Areas and Locations
Welcome to Best NY Pizza — your go-to spot for authentic New York-style pizza in the Tampa Bay area. We have two convenient locations serving Wesley Chapel, Carrollwood, Tampa, and surrounding communities with hand-tossed, stone-fired pizzas, calzones, subs, appetizers, dinners, salads, and desserts made fresh daily.
Best NY Pizza Carrollwood
14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy
Tampa, FL 33618
Phone: (813) 963-7600
Serving the heart of Carrollwood and nearby neighborhoods including:
Northdale • Citrus Park • Westchase • Greater Carrollwood • Lake Magdalene • Town 'n' Country • University Area • Temple Terrace • Keystone
Hours:
Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Best NY Pizza Wesley Chapel
27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd
Wesley Chapel, FL 33544
Phone: (813) 994-2200
Proudly serving Wesley Chapel and surrounding areas including:
Lutz • Land O' Lakes • New Tampa • Seven Oaks • Meadow Pointe • Wiregrass • Pebble Creek • Tampa Palms • Thonotosassa
Hours:
Sunday – Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday – Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Craving authentic NY-style pizza? We serve Lutz, New Tampa, Seven Oaks, Meadow Pointe, and beyond.
Order Online and Enjoy fast delivery, carryout, or dine-in at our Carrollwood or Wesley Chapel location:
Why Choose Best NY Pizza?
- Hand-tossed, thin-crispy New York-style crust baked in a stone-fired brick oven
- Premium ingredients like Grande mozzarella and fresh toppings
- Gluten-free options available
- Family-friendly portions: Personal, Medium, Large, Family, Sicilian
- Fast delivery & carryout to Carrollwood, Wesley Chapel, Northdale, Citrus Park, Westchase, Lutz, and more
- Fresh appetizers, calzones, strombolis, hot subs, Italian dinners, salads, and desserts
Whether you're in Carrollwood, Wesley Chapel, or anywhere in between, we bring the taste of authentic New York pizza right to your door.
Order now or visit us today!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What areas do you serve from your locations?
A: We proudly serve a wide radius around both our locations!
Q: What areas does the Carrollwood (Tampa) Location Serve
A: Northdale, Citrus Park, Westchase, Greater Carrollwood, Lake Magdalene, Town 'n' Country, University Area, Temple Terrace, Keystone, and more.
Q: What areas does the Wesley Chapel Location Serve:
A: Lutz, Land O' Lakes, New Tampa, Seven Oaks, Meadow Pointe, Wiregrass, Pebble Creek, Tampa Palms, Thonotosassa, and surrounding communities.
Q: Do both locations have the same menu and hours?
A: Yes! Both spots offer the same authentic NY-style menu and are open Sunday–Thursday 11am–9 pm, Friday–Saturday 11am–10pm.
Q: Is gluten-free pizza available at both locations?
A: Absolutely — gluten-free crust options are available at both Carrollwood and Wesley Chapel.
Q: Can I order online for delivery or pickup?
A: Yes! Use our easy online ordering system for fast pickup or delivery straight to your door.
Got more questions? Call us or order online today!