Tampa Pizza FAQ: Answers from a New York Pizzeria Owner

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

 

 

 

If you’ve ever wondered why pizza tastes different from place to place — or why some pizza is called “New York–style” when it doesn’t actually eat like it — you’re not alone.

After nearly two decades of making pizza in Tampa Bay, we’ve heard just about every pizza question there is. This page answers the most common pizza questions Tampa locals ask, based on real experience — not marketing myths.

 

Is New York Pizza Different Because of the Water?

You’ve probably heard that New York pizza tastes different because of the water. While water chemistry does play a role, it’s not the full story.

What actually matters more:

• Dough formulation

• Fermentation time

• Mixing technique

• Baking method

Great pizza can be made anywhere if the process is right. The idea that only New York water makes good pizza is an oversimplification.

 

Why Does New York Pizza Fold?

The fold is one of the most recognizable traits of New York–style pizza.

A proper NY slice folds because:

• The crust is thin but strong

• The dough has proper hydration

• The bake sets the structure without drying it out

If a slice cracks, collapses, or droops excessively, the balance is off.

 

Why Does Pizza Taste Different in Florida?

Florida’s climate affects pizza more than most people realize.

Heat and humidity impact:

• Dough fermentation speed

• Gluten development

• Moisture retention

That’s why dough formulas need to be adjusted for Florida conditions. Without those adjustments, pizza can end up heavy, inconsistent, or soggy.

 

What Makes a Pizza Truly New York–Style?

True New York–style pizza isn’t defined by size alone.

It’s defined by:

• Thin, foldable slices

• Balanced sauce and cheese

• A crisp bottom with a chewy interior

• Consistency from slice to slice

If any of those elements are missing, the pizza may resemble NY pizza — but it won’t eat like it.

 

Why Some “NY Pizza” Isn’t Actually NY Pizza

Many pizzerias use the term “New York–style” loosely.

Common shortcuts include:

• Pre-made dough

• Conveyor ovens

• Overloaded toppings

• Heavy, sweet sauces

These shortcuts make production easier, but they change the final result.

Authentic NY pizza relies on restraint, technique, and repetition — not excess.

 

How to Choose a Pizza You’ll Actually Enjoy

The best pizza choice depends on what you’re looking for.

Ask yourself:

• Do you want something light or filling?

• Are you feeding a group or eating solo?

• Do you plan to eat immediately or take it home?

Understanding pizza styles and techniques helps you order with confidence.

 

Learn More or Taste the Difference

If you’re curious about how authentic New York–style pizza is made — or you’re ready to try it for yourself — explore our menu or visit one of our locations in Tampa or Wesley Chapel.