Customer Reviews - Best NY Pizza
New Yorkers Tell Us What They Think
Best NY Pizza Reviews
By far the best pizza in Wesley Chapel! I have order to go before, but this time we ate in. Very clean, staff was super friendly and fast service. Highly recommend!
Homely. A little pricey but good food. Very nice customers. Great for higher end dining, but I went in for a casual lunch.
Went here for the first time and it was great! The pizza and garlic knots were really good, and the staff was friendly. Will definetly be coming back.
If you're used to pizza from the Northeast you know how hard it is to find good pizza down here, this place has very good pizza.
The good is consistently excellent and staff do their jobs very well. Prices are moderate. Excellent dining value.
Great atmosphere and friendly service from the moment you walk through the door! The dishes and pizza were fresh and well seasoned. Well kept and clean dining area. We had a very attentive waitress named Christina who was super amiable and courteous throughout our family gathering with several kids. Glad I discovered this place right in our area!
Great spot to get a pizza. Always stop here when I'm in town visiting my Dad. Great service and the food is delicious.
Lives up to its reputation as the best pizza! Very fresh and made from scratch . Service is a bit slow( hence the four stars and not five) but there were a lot of take out same the day that we went to the restaurant.
PHOTO GALLERY
 |  |  |  |
|---|---|---|---|
 |  |  |  |
 |  |  |  |
 |  |  |
Frequently Asked Questions
Q - Do both locations serve the same menu?
A - Yes. Both locations offer, New York–style hand-tossed pizza, Sicilians, stromboli, calzones, pasta, salads, and appetizers.
Q - Do you make your dough fresh every day?
A - Absolutely. Our dough is made fresh daily using a New York recipe, hand-tossed and stone-fired for authentic flavor.
Q - Can I order online for pickup or delivery?
A - Yes. You can order securely online through our website. Pickup and delivery options are available at both locations through our Toast ordering system.
Q - Do you offer dine-in seating?
A - Yes. Both locations have clean, comfortable dine-in seating where you can enjoy slices, whole pies, and our full menu with table service.
Q - What makes your pizza “authentic New York style”?
A - Our pizzas are hand-tossed, made with fresh dough, premium mozzarella, and cooked in stone-fired ovens for a crisp, foldable slice