New York–Style Pizza in Tampa & Wesley Chapel
Best New York Pizza is a locally owned pizzeria serving authentic New York–style thin-crust pizza and Sicilian pizza in Tampa (Carrollwood) and Wesley Chapel, Florida. We offer dine-in service, pickup, and online ordering.
What Makes Our Pizza New York–Style
Anyone can say “New York–style pizza.” What actually matters is how the pizza eats. A real New York slice should be thin, crisp on the bottom, chewy inside, and strong enough to fold without cracking. That doesn’t happen by accident — it comes from dough, fermentation, and baking technique done the same way every day.
Fresh dough daily • Stone-fired • NY-style
Brooklyn New York Born. Tampa Made
⭐ Founded by Brooklyn natives • Tampa favorite since 2005
Old-School Methods. New York Standards.
For over 20 years, we’ve been bringing real New York pizza to Tampa Bay using the same approach you’d find in a neighborhood slice shop: fresh dough made daily, quality ingredients, and stone-fired ovens.
Best NY Pizza is family-owned and community-driven. We know our regulars by name, we sponsor local teams, and we treat every pie like the one you’ll remember.
No shortcuts. No reheats. Just real New York pizza — every single day.
> “Real New York pizza — every single day.”
> “The best Sicilian in Tampa Bay.”
> “Fresh dough daily, stone-fired, never reheated.”
> “Real NY-style slices. Legendary Sicilian. Total consistency.”
Social Media Influencer
10 Toppings - Best Pizza
Awards & Recognition!
*Creative Loafing
“Best Pizza in Tampa”
*Tampa Bay Times
“Best Pizza in Tampa Bay”
*Nextdoor Neighborhood
"Fave - Favorite"
Our New York Classics
The slices and pies that made us a Tampa Bay favorite. Stone-fired, hand-stretched, and built to fold
Stone-Fired NY Cheese Pizza
Thin, foldable crust, bubbling cheese, and bright tomato sauce. Your classic New York pie, done right.
Sicilian Pizza
Thick, airy crumb with caramelized cheese edges and a hearty layer of tomato and mozzarella.
Pepperoni Lover’s
Cup-and-char pepperoni with crispy edges and melty mozzarella on a foldable NY crust.
What Makes Us Tampa Bay's Best New York Pizza
🍕
Fresh Dough Daily
Our dough is mixed, rested, and hand-stretched every day using our original New York recipe. Never frozen.
🔥
Granite Stone-Fired Ovens
Every pie is baked on stone for that real NY texture — crisp on the outside, soft and foldable inside.
❤️
Total Consistency
Carrollwood or Wesley Chapel, lunch, dinner — every slice tastes like the last great one you had.
Reviews from Customers
★★★★★
“Best Sicilian in town. Crispy edges, soft center, and always piping hot.”
– John D. • Carrollwood
★★★★★
“Tastes just like the slice shops I grew up with in New York. Staff is friendly and fast.”
– Maria G. • Wesley Chapel
★★★★★
“Our go-to for family pizza night. Always consistent and always fresh.”
– Luke P. • Tampa
★★★★★
“Our date night just got upgraded! This pizza is the real deal.”
– Steve & Jen D.
★★★★★
“Best slice outside of Brooklyn! This is my new go-to spot.”
– Carol S.
Inside Best NY Pizza
A quick look at the dough, the ovens, and the slices that keep Tampa coming back
Real Pizzaiola Artistry
.jpeg)
Real Cheese Pull
Real NY-Style Pizza
Hand-Tossed, Stone-Baked, Never Rushed
Real NY-Style Pizza lives and dies by the crust. That’s why we do things the hard way:
-
Our pizza is made only with high-quality mozzarella in both Tampa and Wesley Chapel?
-
Hand-Stretched Daily: No rolling pins, no presses—just skilled hands.
-
48-Hour Cold Proof: We let the flavor develop naturally over two days.
-
Imported High-Gluten Flour: For that authentic strength and chew.
-
Stone Deck Ovens: Baked hot and fast to lock in the crunch.
NY-Style Hand Tossed Pizza
Visit Us Today
Two convenient locations serving Tampa and Wesley Chapel with dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
Carrollwood, Tampa Location
Wesley Chapel Location
Authentic New York-Style Pizza
Best NY Pizza delivers the authentic NY-style pizza Tampa loves and Wesley Chapel craves, serving Tampa Bay communities with fast delivery, takeout, and full catering.
Founded in 2005 by Brooklyn natives Greg and Pat, we craft stone-fired pizzas using fresh daily-made dough (hand-stretched from high-gluten flour), premium tomato sauce, high-quality cheeses, and top-tier ingredients for bold, true New York flavor.
Our menu includes classic and specialty NY-style and Sicilian pizzas, plus Italian favorites like pasta, calzones, strombolis, subs, wings, salads, and appetizers—all in a welcoming, family-friendly setting.
Voted “Best Pizza in Tampa” by Creative Loafing and “Best Pizza in Tampa Bay” by the Tampa Bay Times, we honor our New York roots with custom options for local tastes.
Areas We Serve
Best NY Pizza proudly serves the following communities: Carrollwood, Wesley Chapel, New Tampa, Wiregrass, Seven Oaks, Pebble Creek, Northdale, Lake Magdalene, Egypt Lake-Leto, Carrollwood Village, Plantation, Four Oaks, Carrollwood Cove, Forest Hills, Pinecrest West Park, Lowry Park Central, Seven Oaks, Meadow Pointe, Bridgewater, Estancia at Wiregrass, Esplanade at Wiregrass, Epperson Ranch, Country Walk, Chapel Pines, Avalon Park West, Lexington Oaks, Saddlebrook, The Ridge, Palm Cove, Watergrass, Chapel Crossings.
Italian Classics & Catering
Beyond pizza, we offer pasta, calzones, strombolis, subs, and catering—served in a welcoming, casual setting where customers feel like family.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you make fresh dough every day?
Yes. Our dough is mixed, rested, and hand-stretched every morning, using our original New York recipe.
Are your pizzas stone-fired?
Every pizza is baked in a stone-fired oven for true New York texture — crisp on the outside, soft and foldable inside.
Do you offer gluten-free options?
Yes, we offer gluten-free crust options on select New York-style pizzas. Ask when ordering for availability.
Do you deliver?
Delivery is available through our online ordering partners and third-party services in most nearby neighborhoods.
Which location is closest to me?
Use our locations map or tap “Directions” on the Carrollwood or Wesley Chapel card to open turn-by-turn navigation.
What else is on your menu besides Pizza?
Our menu includes Italian dinners , calzones, strombolis, subs, salads, and appetizers, plus desserts and beverages. We serve by the Slice & full Pizzas.