​

A Local’s Guide to Pizza Styles in Tampa Bay

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

​​

​

​

​

​

​​

​

​

Tampa Bay has become one of Florida’s most diverse pizza scenes. From classic New York slices to Sicilian, Detroit, and Neapolitan pies, locals now have more choices than ever.

But not all pizza styles are the same — and not every style fits every occasion.

This guide breaks down the most common pizza styles you’ll find in Tampa Bay, what defines each one, and how to choose the right style for your taste, appetite, and event.

 

What Makes a Pizza Style Authentic

Every pizza style has defining characteristics. Authenticity isn’t about trends or names — it’s about technique.

True pizza styles are defined by:

• Dough formulation and fermentation

• Bake method and oven temperature

• Crust thickness and structure

• Sauce and cheese balance

• How the pizza is meant to be eaten

When those fundamentals are followed, the style delivers the experience it’s known for.

 

New York–Style Pizza in Tampa

New York–style pizza remains the most popular pizza style in Tampa Bay — and for good reason.

Defining traits include:

• Thin, foldable slices

• Crisp bottom with a chewy interior

• Balanced sauce and whole-milk mozzarella

• Large pies designed to be eaten by the slice

NY pizza works well for almost any situation — quick lunches, family dinners, parties, and late-night cravings.

At Best NY Pizza, this is the style we specialize in, using stone-fired ovens and a dough process refined specifically for Florida’s climate.

 

Sicilian & Grandma Pizza

Sicilian and Grandma-style pizzas are square, thicker, and baked in pans.

Key characteristics:

• Airy interior with a crisp bottom

• Thicker crust than NY-style

• Sauce-forward flavor

• Often finished with olive oil or cheese added after baking

These styles are ideal for sharing and work especially well for groups or catering.

 

Detroit-Style Pizza

Detroit-style pizza has gained popularity in recent years.

It features:

• A thick, rectangular shape

• A light, airy interior

• Cheese baked to the edges, creating a caramelized crust

• Sauce typically applied on top

Detroit-style pizza is rich and filling, making it a good choice for smaller groups or when you’re craving something heavier.

 

Neapolitan Pizza

Neapolitan pizza is traditionally:

• Very thin in the center

• Soft and tender

• Baked quickly at extremely high temperatures

• Made with minimal toppings

While authentic Neapolitan pizza offers a delicate, fresh flavor, it’s best eaten immediately and doesn’t travel as well as other styles.

 

Which Pizza Style Is Right for You?

Choosing the right pizza style depends on the situation:

• Everyday meals & slices: New York–style

• Sharing & catering: Sicilian or Grandma

• Hearty indulgence: Detroit-style

• Fresh, sit-down dining: Neapolitan

Understanding the differences helps you order with confidence.

 

Why New York–Style Pizza Remains Tampa’s Favorite

New York–style pizza strikes a balance few styles can match.

It’s:

• Versatile

• Easy to eat

• Consistently satisfying

• Ideal for groups

That’s why it continues to be Tampa Bay’s go-to style — and why so many locals seek out pizzerias that do it right.

​

Explore the Menu

If you’re craving authentic New York–style pizza, explore our menu or visit one of our locations in Tampa or Wesley Chapel.